Review: “Fiddler on the Roof” in San Jose

by Cari Lynn Pace *

If you are confused by this beloved classic musical appearing as an opera, let’s clarify: Opera San José lends its name, sterling reputation, and actors to this show. They did not convert Fiddler on the Roof to an opera. By definition, in an opera all the dialog is sung. Not so here, as this is the award-winning musical based on the 1964 New York stage production by Harold Prince, then directed and choreographed by Jerome Robbins with book by Joseph Stein, music by Jerry Brock, and lyrics by Sheldon Harnick.

Opera San José has done this beloved musical proud. Under the direction of Crystal Manich, sixty actors and singers, many of whom are operatic virtuosos, play their parts onstage at the beautifully restored California Theatre. They fill the soaring heights of this magnificent soon-to-be-100-years-old 1920’s landmark. It is amazing that the acoustics are so clear in this 1100 seat venue.

Fiddler on the Roof has a simple set that facilitates the clever choreography of Michael Pappalardo and the striking lighting design by Thomas F. Hase. Supertitles in both English and Spanish, easily readable high above the huge stage, enhance the production for audiences seeking such support.

Eugene Brancoveanu as Tevye with the cast of Fiddler on the Roof

George Manahan and Rodrigo Gonzalez-Jacob alternate performances waving the conductor’s baton with 38 musicians in the orchestra.

As Fiddler on the Roof begins, a lone fiddler is precariously perched above the imaginary Jewish settlement of Anatevka, somewhere in 20th century Russia. The villagers gather, their roles clarified by their familial positions and “Tradition”. The stage overflows with glorious voices from Sopranos to Bass, authentically costumed by Chad Phillips.

Tevye, the narrator and poor milkman, bemoans his present fate. This role is masterfully done with humor and power by Tony-award-winning Eugene Brancoveanu. His “If I Were a Rich Man” shows the versatile talent of Opera San Jose’s popular baritone.

Familiar songs continue through the first act, including the whimsical “Matchmaker” sung by Tevye’s three daughters (Nicole Koh, Melissa Sondhi, Laura Corina Sanders.) When Tevye’s eldest pleads for him to break the marriage arrangement he made with the butcher (Doug Brook), he does so by concocting a nightmare for his wife Golde (Shanley Michelle Horvitz) to interpret. Tevye’s plan succeeds. The boisterous wedding begins, with dancing that is astounding and authentic, particularly when bottles are balanced atop hats. Of course the lyrical wedding song “Sunrise, Sunset” can bring tears to many eyes.

The cast of Fiddler on the Roof.

The second act brings poignant scenes of the conflict between traditional life and the changing world. Tevye’s daughters seek love rather than arranged marriages, as Tevye sings “Do You Love Me?” to Golde, with great amusement as she replies.

Their world collapses when they are forced to evacuate Anatevka by military order. They depart with little more than the possessions on their backs and the song of the fiddler on the roof.

At 3 ½ hours, this production is long but worth every minute. As our world changes, this splendid musical survives, with power and hope for a better future.

Playing through November 29, 2026 at the California Theatre, 345 S 1st Street, San Jose.

Click HERE for more information and tickets.

Photos by Steve DiBartolomeo

Cari Lynn Pace is a long-time Bay Area theatre critic whose reviews were regularly featured in the Marinscope Community Newspapers and a member of the San Francisco Bay Area Theatre Critics Circle and Marquee Theater Journalists Association..

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.